On Friday, Google filed an appeal with the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) against a Competition Commission of India (CCI) judgment regarding unfair conduct in the Android mobile device ecosystem. In October of this year, the Indian antitrust body fined the leading technology giant INR ₹1,337.6 (US$162 million) crores for allegedly abusing its influence with respect to the Android smartphone ecosystem.
Since a year ago, CCI has been investigating whether Google has established a formidable presence in five key markets: the market for licensable OS for smart mobile devices in India, the app store for Android smart mobile OS in India, the market for general web search services, the market for non-OS specific mobile web browsers and the market for the online video-hosting platform (OVHP). In its decision in October, the tribunal determined that Google’s demand that device makers pre-install the full Google Mobile Suite and mandate prominent placement of those applications imposed an unfair condition on the manufacturers and violated Section 4(2)(a)(i) of the Act.
The antitrust watchdog said that Google shouldn’t compel device manufacturers to include its suite of applications and that the search engine giant shouldn’t bar vendors from accessing its Play Services APIs and monetary and other incentives to vendors. The regulator also concluded that Google was indeed the market leader in those areas.
Read More: Are high commission rates by Apple and Google leading to a monopolistic atmosphere?
Google would have had to make major modifications to Android and pay a fine of INR ₹1338 crores if the decision had been carried out as written. Some major improvements include not preinstalling Google apps on Android, allowing the listing of alternative app stores on Play Store, and enabling users to choose the default search engine directly from the initial setup page.
After approaching NCLAT on Friday, Google announced that it decided to challenge the CCI’s verdict on Android because it feels the judgment is a huge setback for our Indian consumers and companies that rely on Android’s security features, as well as potentially increasing the cost of mobile devices. The company also stated that it thinks CCI was wrong to disregard the solid documentation provided by OEMs, developers, and consumers proving how the open Android business model encourages competition for the benefit of all parties, including those in India especially. Google is confident that the NCLAT will fully consider the evidence that has been submitted as well as the enormous contribution that Android has made to the rapid expansion and success of the Indian mobile ecosystem.
Read More: Google For India 2022 Event: Announcements
As per Financial Express’s notable sources, Google stated that it had not violated any rules set by the watchdog or the government. However, a token fine could have been imposed in accordance with the competition statutes if the CCI had determined that its actions were anti-competitive. Google believes that the CCI’s fines are penal in nature which are only enforced where there is mala-fide intent. Google also considers the patent rules, which it asserts have been maintained in this instance. According to sources cited by the Financial Express, the company is permitted under patent rules to impose restrictions on the use of open-source versions in order to maintain the ecosystem’s overall security.
The CCI fined Google another INR ₹937 crores (US$113 million) in October for allegedly exploiting the dominance of its Google Play Store and ordered the company to permit app developers to utilize other payment processing systems for in-app purchases or app purchases.
As governments worldwide have started to raise questions or probe about the influence of technology giants, Google is facing increasing scrutiny. In September, Google saw another setback in less than a year when Europe’s top court agreed with EU antitrust investigators that it had misused its dominant position and was slapped with €4.12 billion fine.
Read More: South Korea fines Google and Meta millions for privacy law violations
After discovering violations in Google’s negotiations with publishers to pay them to reuse their content, France fined the company 500 million euros in July of last year. Because of this, Google provided the first set of commitments in December 2021, which were examined, and in May of this year, the internet giant filed further commitments in response to the issues brought up by the French Competition Authority.
An appeal by Google against a decision by Italy’s antitrust authority to fine the company €10 million (US$10.36 million) was rejected by an Italian administrative court in November. The court claimed that Google had not provided clear and immediate information on collecting and using the data of those who accessed their services.
